View Guide to Applying to Neurosurgery Residency
Uncle Harvey’s Guide to Applying to Neurosurgery Residency
“The Wiki Edition”
Originally created by Stem Cell
Preface: So I’m evidently WIKI-challenged. Thus, this is coming to you as a series of regular posts. If someone can figure out how to turn this into a WIKI that can be edited / updated, that would be great - would be best if others can also add useful links. Sorry this preliminary format is a bit disjointed - seems only a limited number of links are permited in each post - violations are punished by complete post disappearance! OK, enough excuses - here it goes:
CONTENTS
Introduction
Chapter 1: Wait a second… is this even a good idea? Is neurosurgery really for me?
Chapter 2: Planning ahead – Topics for those in MS1/2, or earlier
Chapter 3: Do I even have a chance of getting into Neurosurgery?
Chapter 4: Research: How much? What type? How important is it really?
Chapter 5: Help! I just realized I want to do neurosurgery – is it too late?
Chapter 6: Being a medical student on the neurosurgery service
Chapter 7: Learning your stuff as a student: notes on available resources
Chapter 8: Away rotations: When, Where, Why, How?
Chapter 9: Letters of recommendation
Chapter 10: Preparing the application
Chapter 11: Scheduling interviews and life on the trail
Chapter 12: Interviews: what to expect, how to shine
Chapter 13: What should I be looking for in a program?
Chapter 14: Second looks
Chapter 15: Preparing the rank list, and other post-interview issues
Chapter 16: You matched – congratulations!
Chapter 17: You didn’t match – what now?
Chapter 18: Toward residency…
APPENDIX: The programs…
INTRODUCTION
Welcome to Uncle Harvey’s guide to applying to neurosurgery residency! For years Uncle Harvey, (and previously NSmatch) has been a leading source of information for those interested in pursuing a career as neurosurgeons. Every day new topics are added to discussion boards as individuals share their questions, insights and comments about any number of neurosurgery-related topics. The goal of the following “guide” is to provide a collection of some of the most useful and enlightening forum discussions in an organized manner so that applicants can quickly and easily access the information they need when they need it, without having to sift through what has now become thousands of forum topics with tens of thousands of postings. Unlike a published book, this online guide is intended to be a dynamic resource. Useful discussions may be added and outdated topics removed by any registered user, with changes becoming public upon administrator approval (pending WIKI functionality). Tangents, repetition and omissions and occasional misinformation should be expected, along with generous helpings of author’s opinions. As always, please remember that postings may have been written by anyone with a computer and internet access. Enough said. On behalf of the Uncle Harvey community of neurosurgeons, residents and hopefuls who have authored the entries compiled within the threads below, I hope you find the information beneficial. If you have any comments or suggestions on how to improve this resource, please speak up!
======================================================================
CHAPTER 1: Wait a second… is this even a good idea? Is neurosurgery really for me?
Questions about neurosurgery
doubts? regrets?
comments from neurosurgery residents’ spouses…
thoughts on the 88 hour work week
how did you decide on neurosurgery?
how do you commit?
how do you know if you will be good at neurosurgery?
Read this book if you’re still undecided (or even if you’re not!)
======================================================================
CHAPTER 2: Planning ahead – Topics for those in MS1/2, or earlier
Advise to the neurosurgery applicant
Preparing for Step 1 (see also links in 2nd post)
When should I schedule my 3rd year neurosurgery rotation?
How helpful is an MD/PhD?
non-neurosurgery electives
getting all the pieces together (preclinical years)
======================================================================
CHAPTER 3: What must I do to match in neurosurgery? Do I have a chance?
factors that influence competitiveness
Trying to match at a competitive program?
being average
2008 – qualifications vs outcome in match - anecdotes
2009 – qualifications vs outcome in match - anecdotes
2009 – ***official match statistics***
======================================================================
CHAPTER 4: Research: How much? What type? How important is it really?
Research in medical school
Types of Research
what makes a case worthy of a case report?
======================================================================
CHAPTER 5: Discussions about being an aspiring Neurosurgeon-Scientist
Neurosurgeon-Scientists. How do people make it work?
MD/PhD – was it worth it?
Why is a PhD helpful?
Predictors of neurosurgical career choice
======================================================================
CHAPTER 6: Help! I just realized I want to do neurosurgery – is it too late?
Help! Almost MS4!
======================================================================
CHAPTER 7: Being a medical student on the neurosurgery service: Hints and tips
Purpose of Doing a Subinternship
Greenberg highlights
opening / closing 101
Steady hands
Dear annoying medical student
MS 4 - beware of drilling nails in your own coffin
======================================================================
CHAPTER 8: Away rotations: When, Where, Why, How?
Away rotation prerequisites and timing
order of sub-Is
Sub-I presentations
Memorable subinternships???
Did you match where you did a sub-I?
======================================================================
CHAPTER 9: Letters of recommendation
Strong letters of Recommendation
Letters of Recommendation, part 2
======================================================================
CHAPTER 10: Preparing the application
Kenny’s tips on how to get an interview
======================================================================
CHAPTER 11: Scheduling interviews and life on the trail
2009-2010 interview dates
tips for scheduling and life on the road (aka… the beginnings of this guide!)
Interview scheduling tools (from 2008-2009 season)
budgeting for interviews
how many interviews should you do?
2008-2009 interview invitations – see last page for approximate dates invites were sent out in 2008
“On the trail” forum
======================================================================
CHAPTER 12: Interviews: what to expect, how to shine
What to bring to the interview
Discussing research during the interview…
Random notes RE interview experiences, 2009
Classic, gonna-get-‘em interview questions
What you should ask when you interview
The best and worst of 2007 – old but perhaps enlightening
======================================================================
CHAPTER 13: What should I be looking for in a program? How do programs differ?
Finding the right program
Gentleman programs
Case loads
Early operative experience
Surgical PAs… good, bad or indifferent?
Program prestige / geography
Program length
International exposure
Subspecialty strengths
top programs by specialty?
ideal program...?!
======================================================================
CHAPTER 14: Second looks
Second looks
More on second looks
======================================================================
CHAPTER 15: Preparing the rank list, and other post-interview issues
Rank lists
Not ranking programs
Here are 49 of the >300 submitted rank lists for 2009:
2009 program desirability – according to the applicant rank lists (see spreadsheet on last page)
Programs “expressing interest” prior to match day
======================================================================
CHAPTER 16: You matched – congratulations!
2008 Match List
2009 Match List
======================================================================
CHAPTER 17: You didn’t match – what now?
Reactions to not matching
Back-up plan / scrambling tips
======================================================================
CHAPTER 18: Toward residency…
On being a successful resident
Being a resident forum
======================================================================
APPENDIX: The programs…
Interview impressions forum
Subinternships forum
Programs forum
Beware of drilling nails in your own coffin
======================================================================
Special thanks to Stem Cell and Kenny for making this awesome Wiki post happen.

